HomeMade Nutter-Butter Sandwich Cookies

​This post contains affiliate links and we will be compensated for any purchases you make at no additional cost to you. Thanks for your support!
​

     Most of you have already eaten Double Stuff Oreos, right?  Have you tried the Mega Stuff ones? Well, I guess that those ultra creamy filled sandwich cookies spoiled me a bit because recently when my husband and I were on a road trip, we took along some of the famous peanut butter sandwich cookies (that are usually over priced, but that peanut butter flavor tempted us).  The amount of filling in  them was disappointing.  So, of course I got to thinking that I could make a version of my own and add as much filling as I would like! 

     To my husband's delight, my experiment was successful!  The peanut butter filling is so good because I added honey to the recipe.  The cookies start out tender and crunchy, but after a day with the filling on them, they soften up a bit and take on a whole new level of deliciousness. 

The dough for these cookies is stiff enough to roll out to make a sandwich cookie. I don't have a peanut shaped cookie cutter, so I used a round one. You can make these any size or shape that you would like, of course.

    After I made my first batch, Maddy had the idea that Marshmallow Fluff or Nutella would be great to add as another layer of filling to these cookies!  I am going to have to try that next! The cookie version of a FlufferNutter Sandwich! 
     To make these a little more special to look at, I simply stenciled a heart with powdered sugar.  You could do a drizzle with chocolate or a thinner version of the filling if you wanted. 
     If you are in the mood for a delicious peanut butter cookie, give this recipe a try!  Then, pack them up and take them on a road trip! 

Homemade Nutter Butter Sandwich Cookies

​Can't eat peanut butter?  Try some of these cookie recipes:

2 Oatmeal Cookie Recipes

Strawberry Shortbread Sandwich Cookies

Don't forget these peanut butter and marshmallow fluff concoctions! 

Fluffernutter Bites

Root Beer Float Whoopie Pies

Look what I found!